UDC

94(47).084.3+94(510).09

DOI

10.37482/2687-1505-V260

Authors

Vasiliy P. Pashin
Kursk State University;
ul. Radishcheva 29, Kursk, 305000, Russian Federation;
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0357-8970 e-mail: pashinvp@mail.ru

Abstract

In modern conditions, scientific interest in the tragedy of the split of Russian society in the first quarter of the 20th century has been growing. The works being published cover various aspects of the life of white émigrés, including in the Far East. It should be noted that Soviet historiography was created on the basis of Marxist-Leninist methodology. In the second half of the 1980s through the 1990s, some researchers tried, often mechanically, to present historical events in a different light. It is only in contemporary Russia that a clear picture of the historical past has begun to emerge. Based on archival documents from the Foreign Intelligence Service of the Russian Federation introduced into scientific circulation for the first time, this article substantiates the reasons and describes the conditions for the participation and military presence of white émigrés in the Chinese Civil War (1927−1936). The materials are diverse in origin and include reports, summaries and analytical reports of the Harbin and Beijing residencies of the Foreign Department of the Joint State Political Directorate, as well as intelligence reports of various kinds received by Soviet intelligence. Their comparative analysis demonstrated a clear objective picture of the presence of white émigrés in China. It is proved that the share of the white Guard diaspora located in China that took part in the civil war was extremely small. Attempts to formalize the participation of White Guard mercenaries in the Chinese Civil War and put it into legal framework are revealed. The documents found show contractual requirements of the white diaspora leaders for the Chinese authorities to ban the use of the Russian mercenary detachment in punitive operations against civilians outside the three provinces of China. Further, the effectiveness of the military operations of the Russian detachment in Marshal Zhang Zuolin’s army was analysed, as well as the reasons for its demoralization and disintegration. A conclusion is substantiated about the importance of helping Russian citizens who emigrated out of necessity or as a result of delusions and who did not stain themselves by an open conflict with their own people. They must not be cut off completely from their motherland.

Keywords

Far East, white émigrés, K.P. Nechaev, Chinese Civil War, mercenaries, White Guard

References

1. Belov V.M. Beloe pokhmel’e. Russkaya emigratsiya na rasput’i. Opyt issledovaniya psikhologii, nastroeniy i bytovykh usloviy russkoy emigratsii v nashe vremya [The White Movement Hangover. Russian Émigrés at a Crossroads. Studying the Psychology, Sentiment and Living Conditions of the Russian Émigrés Today]. Moscow, 1923. 153 p.
2. Ryklin G.E. Krovavyy ataman [The Murderous Ataman]. Moscow, 1927. 31 p.
3. Pavlovskiy P.I. Annenkovshchina: Po materialam sudebnogo protsessa v Semipalatinske 25/ VII-12/ VIII 1927 g. [Annenkovism: Based on the Materials of the Trial in Semipalatinsk, 25 July – 12 August 1927]. Moscow, 1928. 93 p.
4. Pashin V.P. Strana nomenklaturiya [Nomenklaturia Country]. Kursk, 1992. 288 p.
5. Ioffe G.Z. Krakh rossiyskoy monarkhicheskoy kontrrevolyutsii [The Failure of the Russian Monarchist CounterRevolution]. Moscow, 1977. 319 p.
6. Mukhachev Yu.V., Shkarenkov L.K. Krakh “novoy taktiki” kontrrevolyutsii posle grazhdanskoy voyny [The Failure of the “New Tactics” of the Counter-Revolution After the Civil War]. Moscow, 1980. 64 p.
7. Shalaginov V. Krakh atamana Annenkova [The Failure of Ataman Annenkov]. Chistyakov N.F., Karyshev M.E. (eds.). Neotvratimoe vozmezdie: po materialam sudebnykh protsessov nad izmennikami Rodiny, fashistskimi palachami i agentami imperialisticheskikh razvedok [Imminent Retaliation: Based on the Materials of Trials of Traitors, Fascist Butchers and Imperial Intelligence Agents]. Moscow, 1974, pp. 82–101.
8. Shkarenkov L.K. Agoniya beloy emigratsii [The Agony of White Émigrés]. Moscow, 1986. 236 p.
9. Russkaya voennaya emigratsiya 20-kh – 40-kh godov. Dokumenty i materialy [Russian Military Émigrés in the 1920s – 1940s. Documents and Materials]. Vol. 1. Tak nachinalos’ izgnan’e, kn. 1. Iskhod [Thus the Exile Began. Book 1. The Exodus]. Moscow, 1998. 426 p.; Vol. 1. Tak nachinalos’ izgnan’e, kn. 2. Na chuzhbine [Thus the Exile Began. Book 2. In a Foreign Land]. Moscow, 1998. 751 p.
10. Russkaya voennaya emigratsiya 20-kh – 40-kh godov. Dokumenty i materialy [Russian Military Émigrés in the 1920s – 1940s. Documents and Materials]. Vol. 2. Nesbyvshiesya nadezhdy [Unfulfilled Hopes]. Moscow, 2001. 483 p.; Vol. 3. Vozvrashchenie [The Return]. Moscow, 2002. 555 p.
11. Cherkasov-Georgievskiy V.G. Vozhdi belykh armiy [Leaders of the White Armies]. Smolensk, 2003. 288 p.
12. Volkov S.V. Tragediya russkogo ofitserstva [The Tragedy of Russian Officers]. Moscow, 2001. 507 p.
13. Okorokov A.V. Russkaya emigratsiya. Politicheskie, voenno-politicheskie i voinskie organizatsii. 1920–1990 gg. [Russian Émigrés. Political, Military-Political and Military Organizations. 1920–1990]. Moscow, 2003. 329 p.
14. Semenov G.M. O sebe: Vospominaniya, mysli i vyvody [About Myself: Memories, Thoughts and Conclusions]. Moscow, 2002. 378 p.
15. Mel’gunov S.V. Krasnyy terror v Rossii: 1918–1923 [The Red Terror in Russia: 1918–1923]. Moscow, 1990. 208 p.
16. Ablazhey N.N. S vostoka na vostok: Rossiyskaya emigratsiya v Kitae [From East to East: Russian Emigration to China]. Novosibirsk, 2007. 300 p.
17. Auriline E.E. Rossiyskaya diaspora v Kitae (1920–1950-e gg.) [Russian Diaspora in China (1920–1950s)]. Khabarovsk, 2008. 268 p.
18. Malyshenko G.I. Obshchestvenno-politicheskaya zhizn’ rossiyskogo kazachestva v dal’nevostochnoy emigratsii (1920–1945 gg.) [Social and Political Life of Russian Cossacks in Exile in the Far East (1920–1945)]. Omsk, 2006. 433 p.
19. Bocharova Z.S. Rossiyskoe zarubezh’e 1920–1930-kh gg. kak fenomen otechestvennoy istorii [Russian Diaspora in the 1920s – 1930s as a Phenomenon of Russian History]. Moscow, 2011. 304 p.
20. Revyakina T.V. Rossiyskaya emigratsiya v Kitae. Problemy adaptatsii (20–40 gg. XX v.) [Russian Émigrés in China. Adaptation Problems (1920–1940s)]. Vladivostok, 2002. 105 p.
21. Pisarevskaya Ya.L. Dve Rossii v Manchzhurii: sotsial’naya adaptatsiya i reemigratsiya (20-e – nachalo 30-kh gg.) [Two Russias in Manchuria: Social Adaptation and Re-Emigration (1920s – Early 1930s)]. Novyy istoricheskiy vestnik, 2000, no. 2, pp. 52–70.
22. Cherkashin S.A. Kul’turnye tsentry russkoy emigratsii v Kitae [Russian Cultural Émigré Centres in China]. Obshchestvo. Sreda. Razvitie, 2009, no. 1, pp. 110–116.
23. Balmasov S.S. Beloemigranty na voennoy sluzhbe v Kitae [White Émigrés in Chinese Military Service]. Moscow, 2007. 567 p.
24. Ganin A.V. Chernogorets na russkoy sluzhbe: general Bakich [A Montenegrin in Russian Service: General Bakich]. Moscow, 2004. 240 p.
25. Shuldyakov V.A. Gibel’ Sibirskogo kazach’ego voyska [The Demise of Siberian Cossack Troops]. Book 2. 1920–1922. Moscow, 2004. 607 p.
26. Pashin V.P. Political Sentiments of White Émigrés in the Far East in the 1920s. Vestnik Severnogo (Arkticheskogo) federal’nogo universiteta. Ser.: Gumanitarnye i sotsial’nye nauki, 2021, vol. 21, no. 5, pp. 13–23. DOI: 10.37482/26871505-V126
27. Ganin A.V. Belyy general; krasnyy voenspets Yakov Slashchev-Krymskiy [White Army General; Red Military Specialist Yakov Slashchov]. Moscow, 2021. 256 p. DOI: 10.31168/907245-53-2
28. Zhicheng W. Istoriya russkoy emigratsii v Shankhae [The History of Russian Émigrés in Shanghai]. Moscow, 2008. 573 p.
29. Zonghua Z., Yanhong J., Wenxuan H. Russkaya dvoryanskaya emigratsiya v Kitae posle Oktyabr’skoy revolyutsii [The Russian Noble Emigration in China After the October Revolution]. Yaroslavskiy pedagogicheskiy vestnik, 2017, no. 5, pp. 331–341.
30. Vasilenko N.A. Istoriya rossiyskoy emigratsii v osveshchenii sovremennoy kitayskoy istoriografii [The History of Russian Émigrés as Covered by Modern Chinese Historiography]. Vladivostok, 2003. 220 p.
31. Stephen J.J. The Russian Fascists: Tragedy and Farce in Exile, 1925–1945. New York, 1978. 450 p. (Russ. ed.: Stefan Dzh. Russkie fashisty. Tragediya i fars v emigratsii. 1925–1945. Moscow, 1992. 441 p.).
32. Smirnov S.V., Buyakov A.M. Otryad Asano. Russkie emigranty v vooruzhennykh formirovaniyakh Man’chzhou-go (1938– 1945) [Asano Detachment. Russian Émigrés in the Armed Formations of Manchukuo (1938–1945)]. Moscow, 2015. 320 p.